An appeal is not a second trial. It is a different kind of case, with short deadlines, strict rules, and a record that was built in the trial court. If you lost in the Virginia Beach Judicial Center or in a Workers’ Compensation Commission hearing, or you won and the other side is appealing, the next few weeks matter. Inman & Strickler, P.L.C. handles appeals from Virginia Beach courts and administrative proceedings and works with clients to decide whether an appeal makes sense.
An appeal from the General District Court goes to the Circuit Court, and in most cases the Circuit Court hears the case again from the beginning, which is called a trial de novo. The deadline is short, generally 10 days under Virginia Code § 16.1-106, and an appeal bond and other costs may be required. Because the case starts over, an appeal can be a real second chance, but only if you act in time.
Appeals from the Circuit Court generally go to the Court of Appeals of Virginia. Under Virginia Code § 17.1-405 and following, and Rule 5A:6 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Virginia, a notice of appeal must be filed with the trial court clerk within 30 days of the final judgment or order. Since January 1, 2022, all litigants in civil cases have a right to appeal to the Court of Appeals. Unlike a general district court appeal, you do not get a new trial. You must show the trial court made an error of law, and only on points that were raised at trial.
The most important appellate work often happens before the trial ends. Virginia courts generally will not consider an argument that was not raised with specificity at the time of the ruling, so an objection that is missing or vague can end an issue before the appeal starts. That is why we encourage clients who may appeal to involve appellate counsel early, and why trial lawyers think about the record at every step.
After the Court of Appeals rules, a further appeal to the Supreme Court of Virginia is possible, with a notice of appeal due within 30 days of the Court of Appeals’ decision. The Supreme Court decides which cases it will hear, so a petition has to show why the issue deserves review. These petitions are about legal questions that matter beyond one case.
Workers’ compensation cases follow their own appellate path. A party who disagrees with a Deputy Commissioner’s decision can ask the Full Commission to review it, and a further appeal can go to the Court of Appeals, with a notice of appeal filed with the Commission within 30 days of the review opinion. Because these deadlines are short and the record is limited, claimants and employers should get advice as soon as an adverse opinion arrives.
A conviction in Circuit Court can be appealed to the Court of Appeals, and a misdemeanor conviction in General District Court can be appealed to Circuit Court for a new trial. These appeals also run on short deadlines. We evaluate whether there were errors in the stop, the search, the evidence, or the trial that justify an appeal, and we advise honestly about the likelihood of success.
A typical appeal to the Court of Appeals includes these steps:
- Filing a timely notice of appeal with the trial court
- Ordering the transcript and assembling the record
- Identifying the legal errors that were preserved at trial
- Writing the opening brief and responding to the other side’s brief
- Arguing the case if the court grants oral argument
- Waiting for a decision, which can take months
Appeals cost time and money, and most do not result in a reversal. We help clients weigh the likelihood of success, the cost, the effect on collecting or paying a judgment while the appeal is pending, and whether a settlement or a different path makes more sense. If an appeal is not the right move, we will tell you.
Winning at trial does not always end the case. If the other party appeals, you need to defend the judgment on the record that was made and respond to the issues raised. We help clients protect a favorable result and, where appropriate, negotiate a resolution while the appeal is pending.
Cases decided in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, which includes Norfolk, are appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, with their own deadlines and rules. Our attorneys practice in federal court and can help evaluate whether and how to appeal a federal ruling.
We handle appeals for clients throughout the city, from the Oceanfront and Resort Area to Town Center, Hilltop, Kempsville, Great Neck, Bayside, Princess Anne, Pungo, and Sandbridge. Cases that began in our local courts are often best appealed by attorneys who already know how they are tried. Related services include our civil litigation and jury trial practices.
Steve Strickler represents injured workers before the Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission and the Virginia Court of Appeals, and Matt Weinberg has trial and appellate experience in federal and state court. See our appeals page for more.
Our attorneys have trial and appellate experience in state and federal courts and in the Workers’ Compensation Commission, so we understand both how a record is built and how it is reviewed. We will give you an honest assessment of whether an appeal is worth pursuing.
How long do I have to appeal a general district court judgment?
Generally 10 days from the judgment. An appeal bond and other costs may be required, so act quickly.
How long do I have to appeal a circuit court judgment?
A notice of appeal to the Court of Appeals generally must be filed with the trial court clerk within 30 days of the final judgment or order under Rule 5A:6.
Do I get a new trial on appeal?
From general district court to circuit court, usually yes. From circuit court to the Court of Appeals, no. You must show the trial court made an error of law that was preserved at trial.
Can I appeal a workers’ compensation decision?
Yes. A Deputy Commissioner’s decision can be reviewed by the Full Commission, and a further appeal can go to the Court of Appeals, on short deadlines.
Should I hire an appellate attorney before my trial ends?
It can help. Preserving issues at trial is critical to a later appeal, and an attorney who focuses on the record can advise your trial team.
Call us at 757-486-7055 or contact us to talk with a Virginia Beach appeals attorney about your case. Inman & Strickler, P.L.C. | 575 Lynnhaven Pkwy #200, Virginia Beach, VA 23452